Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Object_Cache::$global_prefix is deprecated in /home/aoiusa/public_html/wp-content/object-cache.php on line 468

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Object_Cache::$blog_prefix is deprecated in /home/aoiusa/public_html/wp-content/object-cache.php on line 469

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Object_Cache::$cache_hits is deprecated in /home/aoiusa/public_html/wp-content/object-cache.php on line 475

Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property WP_Object_Cache::$cache_misses is deprecated in /home/aoiusa/public_html/wp-content/object-cache.php on line 476
Has Prince Charles found his true spiritual home on a Greek rock? – AOI – The American Orthodox Institute – USA

Has Prince Charles found his true spiritual home on a Greek rock?

Visits spark claims of royal’s commitment to Orthodoxy.

Prince Charles
Prince Charles

On Monday night a resplendent yacht docked at the watery entrance to the world’s only monastic republic. A middle-aged man, followed by two bodyguards, stepped on to the jetty of the peninsula in northern Greece and into the “state” known variously as Mount Athos, Aghio Oros and the Holy Mount.

A few monks in black robes and pillar-box hats stood waiting, but, under orders to keep the identity of this particular pilgrim secret, it was a reception without fanfare. Their guest – clean-shaven in contrast to the bearded clerics – was Prince Charles, on his third clandestine retreat to Athos in the past 12 months.

According to friends and associates of the prince, the future head of the Church of England has become enamoured of the Orthodox faith to the point that he has adorned a section of his home at Highgrove with prized Byzantine icons. Many are believed to originate from the Mount, the Orthodox world’s holiest site.

[…]

The prince, like his friend, the composer Sir John Tavener, who converted to Greek Orthodoxy in 1977, is said to be especially drawn to the Orthodox church’s rugged spirituality. Orthodox faithful are allowed to marry up to three times.

Not since the Stuarts has an heir to the throne taken such an intellectual interest in religion. For years Charles, who assumes the title of Defender of the Faith when he becomes king, has displayed an unprecedented interest in denominations as divergent as Islam and Buddhism.

[…]

Read the entire article on the the Guardian website (new window will open).


Posted

in

by

Comments

21 responses to “Has Prince Charles found his true spiritual home on a Greek rock?”

  1. Geo Michalopulos

    The constitutional concerns regarding an open conversion to Orthodoxy are not insurmountable given that England is pretty much a post-Christian culture. However, if it does prove to be difficult, then he could abdicate the throne in favor of his eldest son, William.

    1. Isa Almisry

      That the Anglican Church is post Christian complicates, rather than simplifies a conversion of Charles. You have to believe in Truth to argue there is a reason to convert. Otherwise, going by rote wins.

      Btw, Orthodoxy’s holiest site is in Jerusalem. Christ is risen!

      1. Geo Michalopulos

        true. That’s why I’ve stated on more than one occasion that the first throne of Orthodoxy is (or should be) the patriarch of Jerusalem.

  2. Scott Pennington

    His father is Greek Orthodox. Prince Phillip returned to the Orthodox Church back in 1992 when the Church of England approved women’s ordination.

  3. Fr. Johannes Jacobse

    George, Charles can’t abdicate because he is not king. Did you mean if he becomes king? As a prince, he could probably convert without too much problem since he is not yet the head of the Church of England.

    Run this scenario though: Charles becomes king (ignore for now the speculation that Queen Elizabeth has decided Charles will be skipped — the divorce, Camilla, and all that — and William will be next) and then becomes Orthodox. It would be a crisis of the first order but perhaps one of those ironic twists of history that changes the course of nations. It would recall a time that preceded the Catholic domination of Britain which presently provides the historical rationale for the return of Anglicans to Rome.

    Could God be that merciful toward the wayward Brits? Maybe.

    1. Eliot Ryan

      It would be a crisis of the first order but perhaps one of those ironic twists of history that changes the course of nations.

      Elder Paisios of Mount Athos said it in different words: ‘God can turn a screw in the heads of the powerful of this world and set their minds on the right track.’ This is what causes the ” ironic twists of history “.

      Elder Paisios said that EU will fall apart because the blood shed during the WWII is still warm.
      Many of Prince Charles’ relatives are Orthodox and several of his relatives had been martyred in Russia. According to an Athonite monk ‘Prince Charles is Orthodox in his heart’.

    2. Geo Michalopulos

      Fr, I stand corrected. I guess if he converted now he would be constitutionally ineligible for kingship. I assume in such an event that William would then be heir apparent (but i could be wrong, would HRH Andrew jump to first place?)

  4. Eliot Ryan

    Romanian Elder Fr Dionysius (Ignat) of Colciu Skete on the Holy Mountain. Aged 94, Fr Dionysius has been an Athonite monk since 1926:

    What a good sign that some Westerners are turning to Orthodoxy. The fact that some are also venerating the saints that lived in the West before the Catholic Schism shows how the Holy Spirit is enlightening them to go back to where they left. The West was with the Orthodox Church until all Seven Oecumenical Councils had taken place. Both Orthodox and Catholics are guilty for the Schism, because both lacked love for each other, but at least the Orthodox kept the Faith. The Schism was the work of Satan, because if we had not been separated, the Christian witness to the world would have been titanic, and the devil would not have turned us to all the things of today

  5. Fr. David Hudson

    I have been hearing this story about Prince Charles for years in Romania. May it be blessed!

    Aside from any personal spiritual concerns, it seems to me that the British Royalty have had a good deal of contact with Eastern Orthodoxy through various branches of the extended royal family, including the late Queen Marie of Romania, who was granddaughter of both Queen Victoria and Alexander II of Russia (and mother of Mother Alexandra, late Abbess of Transfiguration Monastery in PA).

    Wikipedia’s article on Prince Charles also notes his long-term interest in Athos and Orthodoxy, as well as other religions.

  6. Michael Bauman

    Although from public statements Prince Charles has made, the Green Patriarch, was one of his attractions.

    1. Geo Michalopulos

      we’ll forego that one…

    2. Roger Bennett

      God works in mysterious ways, Michael. The route I took to Orthodoxy wasn’t always pretty or laudable.

      1. Michael Bauman

        No kidding, I came, in part, through Nietzche and new age cultism. Unfortunately, the philosophy behind the Green Patriarch is not too different. If Prince Charles is looking for the truth, that is what he will find. If not, he’ll keep hold of the lie.

    3. Roger Bennett

      I just saw the dateline – 2004 – and the shabby, gossipy writing. Removed the link from Facebook after I saw that.
      The author hasn’t got a clue about Orthodoxy, or Orthodox monasticism. What kind of cretin would juxtapose “rugged spirituality” with “allowed to marry three times”?

      1. Fr. Johannes Jacobse

        I missed that completely (the dateline). I saw it on the Guardian this morning and took it from there assuming the article was new. Come to think of it, I saw it highlighted in a “related articles” box and just assumed the article was current. Sorry about that readers. Had I noticed the date, I would not have posted it. Still, the comments here were interesting.

  7. cynthia curran

    George, Prince Charles from what I heard belives a lot in global warming.

  8. Peter O’F.

    A few years ago Fr. Andrew Phillips (ROCOR) in the UK queried whether His Royal Highness hasn’t become a formal catechumen of the Orthodox Church, which ISTM would be the only “spiritual ceremony” open to non-Orthodox, besides of course Baptism or Chrismation itself. See http://www.orthodoxengland.org.uk/hrh.htm.

    More recently an OCA priest in Canada (another Commonwealth Realm) wrote at http://www.orthodoxcanada.com/journal/2006-01-02.html:
    “There are numerous indications that the Prince also receives the Holy Mysteries of Communion in the Orthodox Church, from the most strict monastic communities, which raises the question of whether in fact Prince Charles is actually Orthodox. Direct inquiries to those who serve as spokesmen for the Royal Family are met with demure silence: the royal method of avoiding a positive response to a complicated question.” (enphasis added)

    A discussion I saw elsewhere on the WWW (some participants may have been in South Africa, in the Commonwealth but a republic since 1961) expressed the belief or pious hope for “a special corner of heaven” for persons kept from formal Orthodoxy by concerns of State, such as the Prince of Wales finds himself in.

    For more details that seem knowledgeable, see http://www.danielpipes.org/comments/60685.

    With all due respect to Fr. Andrew and others, I find it hard to believe that constitutional sticklers on the one hand, or (small-R!) republicans on the other (British, Irish, *or* Commonwealth), would have let a reversion from the Church of England (and that of Scotland simultaneously) on the part of Charles’ father, Prince Philip, take place without howls heard ’round the world. (I was under a rock in 1992, but at least there, I heard none!) Although it is commonly said that a Royal Spouse only must not be in communion with Rome, IIUC it is also required that s/he be in some form of communion with the English and Scottish State Churches. No such formal Communion is available in Canonical Orthodoxy at this time … though perhaps among one of the uncanonical groups? Or maybe Philip too is a catechumen, perhaps under the idea that when he left Orthodoxy to marry the Queen he “apostatized” in the ancient Orthodox definition of the term (ie, “left Orthodoxy”), meriting Baptism anew someday? I don’t know of a precedent for a Consort leaving the State Church since the ‘formalization’ of the Protestant Succession (as it is called), so I don’t know if doing so would automatically depose the Monarch in favor of the next in succession, or if other action would be required.

    What I didn’t know is that Charles takes his sons on pilgrimage with him. They’re not kids anymore, so presumably there’s some element of free choice on their part too? Curiouser and curiouser, as I’m sure Fr. Geoffrey in Canada http://www.orthodoxcanada.com/index.html would agree.

    (PS: Did you know that when you try to edit a Comment, the text in the box jumps around making it almost impossible to do so? If I didn’t know a thing or two about computers beyond the ordinary, I’d have never figured it out!)

  9. The article from The Guardian on which this blog post is based is nearly six years old. Has the prince visited Mt. Athos since then? If so, I wonder how many times.

  10. […] Prince Charles … and the Holy Mountain? […]

  11. […] Prince Charles … and the Holy Mountain? […]

Leave a Reply to Fr. Johannes Jacobse Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Notice: ob_end_flush(): Failed to send buffer of zlib output compression (0) in /home/aoiusa/public_html/wp-includes/functions.php on line 5481