Postcards from Greece: Phyletism

July 28, 2009 by Fr. Johannes Jacobse · 19 Comments

On a new Postcards from Greece, Fr. Peter Alban Heers explains the heresy of Phyletism, which means placing one’s ethnic identity above the Orthodox faith. Fr. Peter shares with us his ten years of experience of living the Faith and serving the Church in Greece, and in particular the ancient Church of the Thessalonians. On [...]

Filed under Audio, Theology · Tagged with Ecumenical, ecumenical patriarchate, Fr. Peter Herr, Orthodox Theology, phyletism

Support AOI
Recent Comments:
- Ground Zero is American Holy Ground. No Mosque Near Ground Zero
  - Eliot Ryan: We Orthodox have to make certain that we are prepared to welcome and...
  - Scott Pennington: “I’m not sure if there’s such a thing as ‘Islam in its...
  - Samn!: Orr, There’s a fault, I think, in your analogy between Muslim discourse...
  - George Michalopulos: Orr, I agree with you, suffering and martyrdom is the seed of the...
  - Samn!: I’m not sure if there’s such a thing as ‘Islam in its...
  - Scott Pennington: Orrologion and Samn!, There is a problem with the line of reasoning...
  - orrologion: Thanks, Samn! That was a wonderful summary of the state of Islam. I...
  - Samn!: Orr, While it’s true that there are many Islams, modern Islam is rapidly...
  - George Michalopulos: Orrologian, this is naive. Of course most people recognize that...
  - Eliot Ryan: Scott, Thanks for the clarification. Now I understand why some Orthodox...
  - Eliot Ryan: There simply is no way to comprehend this outside of a religious context....
  - George Michalopulos: Peter, I don’t mean to pile on, but I feel that like many in...
- Met. Jonah Keynote Address – The Episcopal Assembly
  - Eliot Ryan: I’ll say it again: Lambrianides’ vision of Balkanized ghetto churches...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: We could also find unity if all the Orthodox became Episcopalians...
  - George Michalopulos: I think that’s what I picked up by +Jonah’s statement...
  - Maxim: You can also find heterodoxy in the see of Rome as well. Unity at the expense of...
  - Fr Tim: You can always find unity in the see of Rome!
  - George Michalopulos: John, you are completely correct. In the interest of love and...
  - John Panos: Wesley, I agree, but the tenor of the recent GOA Clergy Laity was Greek,...
  - Wesley J. Smith: I just listened to + Jonah’s speech about the recent Council. He...
- Tulsa World: Speaker didn’t reflect the church’s views
  - Harry Coin: Good old Elder Paisios. I notice focus on the various sexually fallen and...
  - Eliot Ryan: Harry, Once Elder Paisios chased away from the church a woman who was...
  - Harry Coin: Today I just heard the EP defrocked a now _retired_ priest whose wife died...
  - George Michalopulos: Chris, your analysis reminds me of one of my favorite movie lines...
  - Chris Banescu: God forbid the bishops should actually defrock Fr. Karambis. No such...
  - George Michalopulos: I hear you Harry.
  - Harry Coin: George, We need the bishops you mention to ‘unsuspend’ clergy...
  - George Michalopulos: Michael, I didn’t mean to imply that it did. I was just...
  - Michael Bauman: Scott & George; yes, we should do our best to hold bishops to the...
  - Scott Pennington: Michael, Certainly. And I do not castigate all bishops (as in every...
  - George Michalopulos: That’s a hard task Michael. As someone in the secular world,...
  - Michael Bauman: Scott, Specific bishops do fulfill their responsibility, by the Grace...
- A grand slam and no hitter — all in the same game!
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Not at $5 a crack. We ate before we got to the stadium.
  - Michael Bauman: Great game, just hope you didn’t eat any of the stadium food....
- Patriarch: Pope Is Like-Minded on Morals, Values
  - George Michalopulos: I sense that the reason there’s a palpable sense of joy in...
- No Mosque at Ground Zero
  - Harry Coin: Also consider adding the cemetery and monuments the French keep in...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: No. The Church essentially confirms the sacredness of the place....
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Well, I just wrote an editorial for Catholic Online (explaining...
  - Fr. Peter: My question is this. All of the places we have mentioned are ineed Holy...
  - Fr. Peter: Father, I find myself in agreement with you we need to push the issue of an...
  - George Michalopulos: Alexis, Ground Zero may very well be providential. Not only was...
  - alexis banias: Right on, Mr. Condell! Our spineless politicians should have been...
- Mattingly: Shocking words to the Presbyterians
  - Helga: Father Siarhei is awesome. I look forward to hearing more from him in the future.
  - Chrys: Curiously the opposing “voices” actually agreed: Father Hardun said...
- Turkey offers citizenship to Orthodox archbishops
  - Greg: … it is doubtful whether in the long run the Greek nationalism that was...
  - Dean Calvert: Greg, Read this excerpt from the best book ever written on the Ecumenical...
  - Chris: George, I think we’re all on the same page. Chris
  - Greg: For some reason I thought that because the Patriarch was Ecumenical there would...
  - Dean Calvert: Dear Greg, First of all, there’s no reason at all that the...
  - Greg: Could the next Ecumenical Patriarch be Armenian, or Syrian, or Bulgarian? If no,...
  - George Michalopulos: Chris, I understand what you’re saying, but in some ways...
  - Chris: I have to be a little direct with my opinion on this, forgive me. But having a...
  - George Michalopulos: Fr John, there’s much wisdom in what you write. I’m...
  - Harry Coin: I think the Turks, formely Americans, who might yet be dual citizens and...
  - Fr. John: I think Kemal Ataturk was thinking along the same lines when he made the fez...
  - Harry Coin: George, I think that as the possibilities of modern life reach the rural...
- More from Fr. Zakariah Boutros
  - Eliot Ryan: Despite all the miracles they had seen, the Apostles were fearful and...
  - Chrys: Very true! Of course, lest I be misconstrued, I am grateful even for one. There...
  - Chris Banescu: Even 3 more like him would be enough to have an enormous impact!
  - Chris Banescu: By walking in the faith and fearlessly proclaiming the Lord and speaking...
  - Chrys: Inspiring and courageous. The power of his faith also exposes the moral...
  - Moussa: Fr. Zakaria Botros is a Coptic Orthodox priest who has been taking on the world...
- Colson: Christians and Civil Disobedience
  - Fr. Peter Dubinin: I agree with many who observe that to confine the reality of...
- Finding the Balance: Privacy and the Civil Society
  - Michael Bauman: Harry, the manner in which we attempt to communicate the goods and...
  - Harry Coin: Michael, it’s fairly clear that ‘commercials’ as we know...
  - Michael Bauman: Perhaps another way to frame the issue is one of modesty, intimacy, and...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: You’re welcome, Fr. Gregory. Also posted on OT:...
  - Fr Gregory Jensen: Thanks for the link Father!
  - Harry Coin: In what way do we lose things distictive to us, as the Noonan article says,...
- OCA releases strategic plan for public comment
  - Geo Michalopulos: BTW, now that you brought it up, does anybody know what’s...
  - Scott Pennington: Fr. John, You may be right, and that is truly sad. As I mentioned...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Revised: 5:30pm, EDT. The term was borrowed from the great split...
  - Fr. John: I think the writers of the statement are assuming familiarity among readers...
- If states were countries…
  - Geo Michalopulos: Cynthia, you’re right about the demographics but one of the...
  - Peter O'Filon: I wouldn’t put too much “faith” in their work: A...
Recent Trackbacks:
- OrthodoxNet.com Blog: Ground Zero is American Holy Ground. No Mosque Near Ground Zero
- World of Islam: History of the Moors of Spain
- OrthodoxNet.com Blog: Alexi Giannoulias, Democratic Senate Nominee, Supports Homosexual Marriage
- AOI Observer -- Topsy.com: Tweets that mention St Katherine College: Orthodox Undergraduate Education
- World of Islam: Mohammed and Islam: A comparison with orthodox Christianity

Ecumenical Patriarchate: American 'Diaspora' must submit to Mother Church 342 comment(s)
How Are We to Respond to Clergy Sexual Misconduct? 80 comment(s)
Over 1/2 Million New Members to be received into the Holy Orthodox Church 70 comment(s)
Greek Orthodoxy, the Ecumenical Patriarchate, and the Church in the USA 61 comment(s)
Tampa Native Metropolitan Nikitas to become a Turkish citizen 55 comment(s)
'ClimateGate' and the EP: Wagon hitched to the wrong horse? 53 comment(s)
The Sounds of Silence? 53 comment(s)
Green Patriarch: "... absolute limits to our survival are being reached" 51 comment(s)
Patriarchal flag to fly over GOA churches? 51 comment(s)
GOA Deacon responds to Dn. Eric Wheeler 50 comment(s)

Links

The American Orthodox Institute is a research and educational organization that engages the cultural issues of the day within the Orthodox Christian moral tradition. Read Fr. Hans Jacobse's Orthodox Leadership in a Brave New World, the cover article from the Fall 2007 issue of AGAIN Magazine.

AOI Orthodoxy-Hellenism discussion quick-links

EP: American ‘Diaspora’ must submit to Mother Church

Archbishop Demetrios compares Obama to Alexander the Great

OCL Responds to EP talk at Holy Cross Seminary

Met. Jonah to Old World bishops: Hands off the American Church!

Transcription of Met. Jonah's speech on Orthodox unity in America

Greeks losing interest in Hellenism

Met. Jonah apologizes for ‘uncharitable’ remarks directed at EP

Met. Gerasimos blasts Met. Jonah for “persecuting” the Church of Constantinople