The American Orthodox ‘Historiographical Problem’

July 21, 2009 by John Couretas · 117 Comments

Each age tries to form its own conception of the past. Each age writes the history of the past anew with reference to the conditions uppermost in its own time. — Frederick Jackson Turner Here’s a new site worth a visit. The Society for Orthodox Christian History in the Americas has launched a new blog [...]

Filed under Audio, History, Orthodox Church, Podcast · Tagged with Archbishop Meletios Metaxakis, jurisdictionalism, Matthew Namee, Society for Orthodox Christian History

Support AOI
Recent Comments:
- The man Bishop Savas praises
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: All absolutely accurate, Fabio. I read Boff and Gutiérrez years...
  - Chris Banescu: Yes, he posted that in order to appear “balanced” once AOI...
  - Chris Banescu: Peter, On August 30, 2010 in a discussion on Bishop Savas’...
  - Noël Joy Plourde: Did you read the thread? Please quote me the part where the bishop...
  - Noël Joy Plourde: With all due respect, I was not defending Bp. Savas’ statements...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Actually, the recklessness may be doubled if it turns out Human...
  - Andrew: Professor, what I see in this thread is a bishop being held accountable for his...
  - Peter Bouteneff: Chris, it is both inaccurate to speak of him in terms of an...
  - Fabio L Leite: Just a note on Liberation Theology, with quotes from one of its fathers....
  - John Sanidopoulos: I must say, this is quite the ridiculous, if not purely malicious,...
  - Chris Banescu: So Peter, the fact that Bp. Savas embraces Liberation Theology, which...
  - Peter Bouteneff: Here’s what I see happening in this thread. Bp Savas takes note in a...
- Robert P. George calls out Frank Schaeffer
  - Jean: Sorry Fr., I didn’t punctuate or edit. See revised: “not to see any...
  - cynthia curran: Well Frank’s main problem is not political, he was always...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Ecstatic? About an Obama win? Where?
  - Jean Busby: Read all this with interest. I was surprised when I read Frank’s blog...
  - cynthia curran: That’s true about his book there is a lot of sexaul language and...
  - alexis banias: Franky just needs to shut up, really. First, we need to pray for him...
- Burning the Koran
  - barbara: Here’s what the Mother Church has to say about Islamophobes: People who...
  - Brian Jackson: Fr. Peter, Bless! “This “pastor” is no better than the radicals...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Bravo Fr. Peter! Excellent piece.
- Fr. Preble: Duties to the State from a Romanian Orthodox Church Perspective
  - Eliot Ryan: St. John, Archbishop of Shanghai and San Fransisco too came here to US to...
  - Antiochian: I wish people who came from countries without rule of law (middle east,...
  - cynthia curran: True but sometimes Orthodox misunderstand what Orthodox thought in...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Yes. This too is why Orthodoxy has problems organizing itself in...
  - Fabio L. Leite: I like the use of the generic word “rulers” because it...
- OCA summarizes Met. Hilarion’s visit
  - George Michalopulos: Matthew, what exactly do you mean? What exactly about “the...
  - George Michalopulos: Tom, I resent your characterization of Archbishop Robert Duncan...
  - Tom Dittmer: Not if they can get Bob Duncan and his crew of ACNA wackaloons to convert....
  - Matthew: Well, if it’s not up to Moscow Patriarchate it’s up to OCA to take...
- CNN’s “World’s Untold Stories” to examine Greek Orthodox Community in Turkey
  - Dean Calvert: Cynthia, A warm water port was the dream of Czars going back to the time...
  - cynthia curran: Maybe, I’m ignored of 19 century history but I think Russia was...
  - Dean Calvert: Hi Everyone, Russian/Turkish relations are expanding because trade...
  - Harry Coin: Will, they wrote it almost certainly because that’s what someone in a...
  - Will Crowe: The CNN story says, “To this day, Orthodox Christians around the...
- The Ground Zero Church/Mosque
  - Eliot Ryan: Fr.Gregory: All I know for certain is that I don’t know enough about Islam...
  - Fr Gregory Jensen: Eliot, Thanks for the links–they look informative. Without...
  - Eliot Ryan: Fr. Gregory: I believe you want to use the strategy of St. Paul, the...
  - Fr Gregory Jensen: Eliot, Thanks for your comment and question. Like I said in the...
  - Eliot Ryan: Fr. Gregory: What do you have in mind when you say should we be “more...
  - Fr Gregory Jensen: Eliot, I see, thank you! So do you think we should be more assertive...
  - Eliot Ryan: Fr. Gregory: IMO, the proposal to build a mosque is provocative, defiant,...
  - Fr Gregory Jensen: Eliot, Thank you for your clarification. I don’t doubt that...
  - Eliot Ryan: Oops … The situation we are in today is paradoxal.
  - Eliot Ryan: Chrys, Yes, your reading of my comments was correct. St Antony told Abba...
  - Eliot Ryan: The situation we are in today is paradox. I believe it is the result of a...
  - Chrys: Eliot, your response is better. But then, irritation toward others is simply the...
- A patriarch who ‘generally speaking, respects human life’
  - Mary Christine Erikson: I praise God that someone is doing a good job. I get rather...
  - Michael Bauman: Mary Christine Erikson, I too am a convert although the distinction...
  - Mary Christine Erikson: Here is shown the great weakness of the modern Orthodox notion,...
- Ground Zero as Metaphor: A Crossroads for America and Orthodoxy?
  - George Michalopulos: Cal, something has been bothering me about this latest idiocy,...
  - George Michalopulos: Cal, you are so kind to me. Too kind. Truth be told, this latest...
  - Cal Oren: With his usual broad grasp of history, once again George Michalopulos has...
- Dr. Peter Bouteneff: Speaking the truth in love
  - George Michalopulos: Andrew, we don’t have to suppose what would happen if an...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: You are on to something Cynthia although I would turn the last...
  - cynthia curran: Well, this came to mind. Not on the homosexual issue since a tiny...
  - Chris Banescu: Andrew, You raise an important point about the dangers many righteous...
  - Andrew: Lets ask ourselves if Fr. Hardun had used such tough love on an Orthodox...
  - Eliot Ryan: … I see. Thank you Father. The truth was spoken gently. His words may...
  - George Michalopulos: Dr Bouteneff: thank you for this measured and eloquent apologia...
  - Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Andrew. Agreed. The distinction that Dr. Bouteneff draws is a...
  - Eliot Ryan: But the love was present also in the simple fact that Fr Siarei respected...
  - Andrew: Professor Bouteneff deserves praise for this well though out article. His...
- Salvation in Christianity. The martyred Father Daniel Sysoyev
  - Eliot Ryan: Part II – How to obtain Salvation? The matter is that, on the one...
  - Eliot Ryan: As a tribute to the memory of the Martyred Father Daniel Sysoyev I took the...
- James Taranto: Common sense is to be avoided just because it is common
  - Fr John: This audio post simply reiterates commonplaces of the culture wars and sheds...
  - Eliot Ryan: Freedom — and common sense — are under attack in this country MADGSXR (MAD...
- Former Gov. Pataki, George Demos: We Must Rebuild Greek Orthodox Church At Ground Zero: Updated »
  - George Michalopulos: Harry, that’s part of the problem. In the GOA there is no...
- Mosque of conquest?
  - Joe Hegyi III: It took hundreds of years to win back our lands from the Muslims the...
- Chaplains in no-win situation on ‘don’t ask’
  - George Michalopulos: Cynthia, the issue was never one of whether homosexuals can fight....
  - George Michalopulos: Fr Peter, thank you for clarifying that. Honestly, I didn’t...
  - cynthia curran: Well, to be gays in the military are kind of a gray issue. In anicent...
  - Fr. Peter Dubinin: Dear RZ – thank you for your question; many have the same...
  - Fr. Peter Dubinin: George – thanks for your kind words; you speak truth. I do not...
  - RZ: Fr Peter, as an Orthodox priest, how do you deal with people of other non-Christian...
Recent Trackbacks:
- Preachers Institute: Obama, Stem Cell Research and Orthodox Christianity
- Ground Zero | AOI Observer -- Topsy.com: Tweets that mention George Demos: We Must Rebuild Orthodox Church
- OrthodoxNet.com Blog: Fr. Johannes Jacobse: Paschal Message 2009
- Pseudo-Polymath: Tuesday Highlights
- OrthodoxNet.com Blog: A Secular Argument Against Gay Marriage

Ecumenical Patriarchate: American 'Diaspora' must submit to Mother Church 342 comment(s)
A patriarch who 'generally speaking, respects human life' 70 comment(s)
Ground Zero is American Holy Ground. No Mosque Near Ground Zero 54 comment(s)
Robert P. George calls out Frank Schaeffer 39 comment(s)
Report: Greek Orthodox bishops in U.S. may take Turkish citizenship 31 comment(s)
Praying for Christopher Hitchens 26 comment(s)
The man Bishop Savas praises 26 comment(s)
Greeks losing interest in Hellenism 25 comment(s)
Finding the Balance: Privacy and the Civil Society 23 comment(s)
The Future of the GOA Rests On 32 Celibate Clergy 17 comment(s)

Links

The American Orthodox Institute is a research and educational organization that engages the cultural issues of the day within the Orthodox Christian moral tradition. Read Fr. Hans Jacobse's Orthodox Leadership in a Brave New World, the cover article from the Fall 2007 issue of AGAIN Magazine.

AOI Orthodoxy-Hellenism discussion quick-links

EP: American ‘Diaspora’ must submit to Mother Church

Archbishop Demetrios compares Obama to Alexander the Great

OCL Responds to EP talk at Holy Cross Seminary

Met. Jonah to Old World bishops: Hands off the American Church!

Transcription of Met. Jonah's speech on Orthodox unity in America

Greeks losing interest in Hellenism

Met. Jonah apologizes for ‘uncharitable’ remarks directed at EP

Met. Gerasimos blasts Met. Jonah for “persecuting” the Church of Constantinople